Transcript
Speaker 1 [00:01]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [00:03]: Good evening everybody and thank you very much for attending this meeting of Exmouth Town Council’s Planning Committee on Monday the 8th of June to consider the matters on the agenda.
Speaker 1 [00:20]: Agenda item 1 is apologies for absence, we have them from David Paul.
Speaker 1 [00:24]: We have a note that Councillor Conduit will be a little bit late.
Speaker 1 [00:29]: Do we have anything from Councillor Coleman?
Speaker 1 [00:33]: Yeah, Councillor Coleman’s in France.
Speaker 1 [00:36]: Oh, OK.
Speaker 1 [00:36]: So he apologises.
Speaker 1 [00:38]: Legitimate reason not to be here then.
Speaker 1 [00:40]: Oh, that’s dying, isn’t it?
Speaker 1 [00:41]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [00:42]: OK.
Speaker 1 [00:42]: So I think that’s everybody.
Speaker 1 [00:45]: We do have a public speaker today.
Speaker 1 [00:47]: Sam, Welcome.
Speaker 1 [00:51]: So just to outline how public speaking works, representations will be taken ahead of each discussion by Councillors on each application.
Speaker 1 [01:01]: Where are we up to?
Speaker 1 [01:02]: Representations may be up to 3 minutes.
Speaker 1 [01:04]: Speakers must begin within their representation by stating their name and interest in the application and whether they are supporting or objecting to the application.
Speaker 1 [01:16]: Speakers must endeavour to avoid repeating themselves or earlier comments by others, but there are no others at my discretion I could ask for.
Speaker 1 [01:25]: No, we don’t need to worry about that one.
Speaker 1 [01:29]: OK, so this is for application.
Speaker 1 [01:32]: It’s the first one on the agenda anyway, so I will just go through just so because it’s right at the start anyway.
Speaker 1 [01:40]: I’ll just go through.
Speaker 1 [01:42]: So it’ll just be a couple of minutes or so.
Speaker 1 [01:44]: Agenda item 2 is to confirm the minutes of the meeting held on the 26th of May.
Speaker 1 [01:50]: Does anybody have any comments on those?
Speaker 1 [01:51]: Cancer dumper propose.
Speaker 1 [01:53]: OK Anybody happy that Councillor Ross are happy to 2nd them?
Speaker 1 [01:57]: All those in favour, thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [02:00]: Agenda item 3 is to receive any declarations of interest from members.
Speaker 1 [02:06]: Does anybody have any councillor DC?
Speaker 1 [02:08]: I’m not sure how pertinent it is Chair, but just to say I go to the little Them Together meetings where this first item has been discussed at those meetings, but I’m still very open minded.
Speaker 1 [02:22]: OK.
Speaker 1 [02:22]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [02:23]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [02:23]: No, that’s cool.
Speaker 1 [02:24]: Councillor Rosser.
Speaker 1 [02:27]: OK, thank you.
Speaker 1 [02:27]: You want declarations for other?
Speaker 1 [02:32]: Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1 [02:33]: This is for for all, all items my possible membership of the of the what is it called now national landscape.
Speaker 1 [02:44]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [02:44]: Yes, OK.
Speaker 1 [02:47]: I would also like to it is for one of the ones in my ward.
Speaker 1 [02:53]: Where are we?
Speaker 1 [03:00]: Excellent, Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [03:04]: So where are we?
Speaker 1 [03:10]: So for application 260616 full at the Grove, I know the landlord there and I have played music there in the past.
Speaker 1 [03:20]: However, the applications come from the brewery.
Speaker 1 [03:23]: I think I’m OK to still speak on that.
Speaker 1 [03:27]: I have no, you know, no interest at all in in, in in promoting them or otherwise OK.
Speaker 1 [03:38]: Urgent business is agenda item 4, there is none and agenda item 5 is tree in advertising consent applications which surprisingly there are none.
Speaker 1 [03:47]: So we moved to gender item 6 planning applications.
Speaker 1 [03:50]: There are none in Brixington Cherry.
Speaker 1 [03:55]: That’s why you’re here, right?
Speaker 1 [03:58]: None in Halston.
Speaker 1 [03:59]: We have we, so we moved to Littleham.
Speaker 1 [04:02]: So the first one is planning application 260780443 Glebe Close.
Speaker 1 [04:09]: The proposal is for a formation of a new pedestrian footpath from Glebe Close through the rear garden land at 3 Glebe Close to provide pedestrian access to adjoining land associated with Litlam Church of England Primary School, including minor groundworks and associated boundary alterations if required.
Speaker 1 [04:30]: We will now hear from our public speaker.
Speaker 1 [04:32]: Sam.
Speaker 1 [04:33]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [04:35]: Thank you so much for having me here.
Speaker 1 [04:37]: I’m Sam Burnett, the minister of the Wave, who are proposing the application, although it’s coming through East Devon Council I believe.
Speaker 1 [04:49]: Firstly, can I just say I’m really thankful for being here and I’m really torn by my application because I really want it to happen.
Speaker 1 [04:58]: I also really don’t want to upset the neighbours and I know there have been some some objections.
Speaker 1 [05:06]: What we’re talking about is creating a, a gate into the bottom half of the school field so that we can run community space for gardening.
Speaker 1 [05:15]: We currently run a community garden just over the road at Littleham Hub.
Speaker 1 [05:21]: We’ve outgrown that space and we’d like a larger space to to be able to grow food, to engage the community in community sort of outreach and activities, to be able to feed those who need feeding and support mental health and be there for the community there.
Speaker 1 [05:41]: So This is why it’s such a difficult one for me because I do want it to happen.
Speaker 1 [05:45]: But the worst thing would be to upset the neighbours around because I really want them to see it as a positive thing.
Speaker 1 [05:51]: There’s been discussions around parking.
Speaker 1 [05:55]: I can’t do a huge amount about parking except for the fact that we’re in Littleham and we’re for the people of Littleham.
Speaker 1 [06:00]: So my hope would always be people would walk from the estate to the space and abide the abide by the laws of where you’re allowed to park and where you’re not allowed to park.
Speaker 1 [06:11]: I do know there were some concerns about whether the school would have access in and out and it would become a very busy space.
Speaker 1 [06:20]: This is not an access point for the school.
Speaker 1 [06:23]: There is a fence the other side that blocks it from the main school playing field so that the school can have access to our garden space when the gate to the community is closed.
Speaker 1 [06:34]: And the community can have access to the garden space when the gate to the school is closed.
Speaker 1 [06:39]: But it isn’t an entrance point for any other users other than the community garden and outdoor space.
Speaker 1 [06:46]: So I guess there was a conversation around drainage.
Speaker 1 [06:52]: I believe there’s been some work done to, to, to change or to support or stop the drainage issues in that space.
Speaker 1 [07:02]: And I know that the housing company who built the, the housing nearby have been on site to try and sort some drainage out more recently as well.
Speaker 1 [07:10]: And that’s an ongoing process.
Speaker 1 [07:12]: So that’s kind of a bit of background information about what we are and why we’re there.
Speaker 1 [07:18]: And, and you know, I hope, I hope it goes ahead, but equally I, I don’t want to upset the neighbours.
Speaker 1 [07:26]: So it’s kind of where we are with it.
Speaker 1 [07:31]: For context, can I just say that we were aware of this application through our Section 106 working party because there was an appetite to try and support it through Section 106 as an open space community project.
Speaker 1 [07:46]: But as part of that there there’s a range of due diligence that needs to be done.
Speaker 1 [07:52]: And one of them was around the access point, particularly around safeguarding issues with the school, that a separate access point was potentially created for the community garden.
Speaker 1 [08:03]: We understand that three Greek 3 Glebe Close is District Council owned.
Speaker 1 [08:08]: I think it’s a tenanted property.
Speaker 1 [08:10]: It’s not privately owned, it’s a tenanted property.
Speaker 1 [08:13]: So this applications come forward from East Devon District Council in respect of one of its own properties.
Speaker 1 [08:19]: We don’t know what the situation is with the tenant of that house.
Speaker 1 [08:22]: We have to assume that East Devon has consulted that tenant and that they’ve agreed to having the part of their garden, if you like, adapted into a footpath to create that access point.
Speaker 1 [08:37]: OK, thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [08:40]: If I just read through and thank you for what you’ve said.
Speaker 1 [08:44]: It’s quite rare to to have somebody come in and speak in at a meeting where they, they do want something to happen, but also they get, you know, to actually be able to.
Speaker 1 [08:53]: Great.
Speaker 1 [08:56]: So the we’ve had five representations which object to the increased Hwy safety, much as has just been said which object to the increased Hwy safety risks and parking.
Speaker 1 [09:06]: Pressure from additional access in onto Litlam Rd, Loss of residential amenity through noise disturbance and reduced privacy.
Speaker 1 [09:14]: Potential for antisocial behaviour.
Speaker 1 [09:17]: Existing flood risk concerns.
Speaker 1 [09:19]: A lack of demonstrated need given alternative established accesses.
Speaker 1 [09:26]: Councillor David Paul objects agreeing with local residents A footpath would be intrusive with a loss of privacy with overlooking and security issues.
Speaker 1 [09:35]: Flooding is definitely a problem.
Speaker 1 [09:36]: Those drain can’t cope with water coming off the fields and has led to water getting into at least one house with a drain being blocked.
Speaker 1 [09:43]: Parking is also a problem.
Speaker 1 [09:45]: There’s already an issue with parents parking by the school.
Speaker 1 [09:49]: Have we had any sort of documentation or confirmation about any work that’s been done there in terms of drainage?
Speaker 1 [09:59]: OK, OK, that’s fine.
Speaker 1 [10:02]: So we will go to the committee now.
Speaker 1 [10:04]: Councillor Graham, DC Graham.
Speaker 1 [10:08]: Yes, Thank you.
Speaker 1 [10:08]: Chair, I, I’m generally in favour of this particular scheme.
Speaker 1 [10:15]: I will say that now I think that as long as we can satisfy the concerns if you like about security, it is a very short stretch of paths.
Speaker 1 [10:26]: It is between two gardens effectively.
Speaker 1 [10:30]: And I think there’s as far as I know.
Speaker 1 [10:34]: And may I ask the speaker just about the the fencing arrangement Chair through you Can I, may I just ask one question, Sam, the sort of security or the sort of fencing that’s going to sort of isolate this path is would that give the privacy?
Speaker 1 [10:50]: Yeah, I mean the the plan is for a 6 foot fencing with lockable gate into the space, but that’s that was that’s what I thought from the little them together meeting.
Speaker 1 [11:01]: So I just thought I’d use this meeting to confirm, to confirm that I don’t think, I personally don’t think parking would be an issue.
Speaker 1 [11:11]: I think I, I concur that it is.
Speaker 1 [11:14]: It’s a very local scheme for primarily for the people who live very locally to it.
Speaker 1 [11:19]: And I don’t see vehicles being a particular issue there at all.
Speaker 1 [11:25]: I mean, obviously we know that that Littleham has areas of significant issues of deprivation.
Speaker 1 [11:30]: I know there have been initiatives from our own climate officer to try and get people growing their own, if you like, in that particular vicinity and to encourage that as we go forward.
Speaker 1 [11:44]: And obviously with the cost of food nowadays, it is I think a good initiative.
Speaker 1 [11:48]: It’s expanding on the work that the wave we’re already doing.
Speaker 1 [11:52]: So All in all, Chair, I don’t have the same level of concerns, shall we say that some of the objections that you read out and I would support this application.
Speaker 1 [12:03]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [12:04]: Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [12:06]: Councillor Rosser.
Speaker 1 [12:08]: Hello.
Speaker 1 [12:09]: To start with, I think the issue about drainage is, is a bit of the red herring really, because it’s the problem with drainage at the moment.
Speaker 1 [12:15]: Well, it’s there.
Speaker 1 [12:16]: It’s not going to be any worse because of the path.
Speaker 1 [12:18]: Although having said that, they’re talking about a tarmac path and I think I’m surprised at that because they could make it a poorest path, which would mean that there wouldn’t be any more surface water going needing to be drained away, right.
Speaker 1 [12:34]: So, yeah, there, there seems to be some misunderstanding in the local community about the, the, the purpose of this path.
Speaker 1 [12:41]: I mean, people are, are thinking, oh, you know, is it going to be an access to the school?
Speaker 1 [12:45]: Well, no, it isn’t.
Speaker 1 [12:47]: Is it going to be, are there going to be parking problems?
Speaker 1 [12:50]: Well, as we’ve heard it’s for local people who will walk and maybe cycle, maybe a few will, you know disabled people will need to to drive, but it’s very much a a skin to bring the community together.
Speaker 1 [13:04]: I’m very much in support of it.
Speaker 1 [13:06]: I’m happy to 2nd a proposal for support.
Speaker 1 [13:10]: Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [13:10]: Does anybody else have a comment at all?
Speaker 1 [13:13]: Councillor come under it.
Speaker 1 [13:14]: Yeah, I just want to go.
Speaker 1 [13:16]: It’s a lockable gate so it’ll it won’t be Open Access for anybody to use any time, day or night.
Speaker 1 [13:27]: Excellent.
Speaker 1 [13:28]: Councillor Dumper Tim.
Speaker 1 [13:30]: Yeah, Thank you, Joe.
Speaker 1 [13:32]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [13:32]: Just to ask through you, Sam, if, if, if these concerns are about access to the school, how how is it proposed that you prevent that happening?
Speaker 1 [13:46]: I suppose it it is an access to our community garden.
Speaker 1 [13:51]: It’s not an access to the school.
Speaker 1 [13:54]: And so our agreement when the school art in other access, it’s not that the school will have the codes or the access to this.
Speaker 1 [14:09]: So effectively when one gate is closed, the other one or when one gate is open the other one’s closed and the people will leave there and then the other way round.
Speaker 1 [14:17]: OK, that’s right.
Speaker 1 [14:20]: OK, If we don’t have any more comments, should we go to the vote because we do have a proposal and a seconder for no objection, all those in favour, that’s unanimous.
Speaker 1 [14:32]: OK, thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [14:34]: We’ll just pause there for a second.
Speaker 1 [14:35]: You can stay if you want, Sam, I wouldn’t recommend it.
Speaker 1 [14:41]: OK, no, that’s fine.
Speaker 1 [14:44]: So the recording will continue, but we’ll just wait a few seconds.
Speaker 1 [14:47]: OK, great.
Speaker 1 [14:59]: So we will now move to Planning application 260962 Full 88 Foxholes Hill.
Speaker 1 [15:11]: The proposed demolition of a site.
Speaker 1 [15:15]: Richmond Road is the next one.
Speaker 1 [15:16]: Oh yes, there it is.
Speaker 1 [15:17]: Planning.
Speaker 1 [15:17]: No thank you.
Speaker 1 [15:18]: Planning application 260795 Full 29 Richmond Road to alter an existing garage into a bedroom and utility room.
Speaker 1 [15:29]: We have no comments from consultees and no other representations.
Speaker 1 [15:34]: Councillor David Poor has said that he has no objection and this pertains to Exmouth Neighbourhood Plan Policy EB2, that it must be mindful of surrounding building styles.
Speaker 1 [15:48]: Councillor Mike Rosser Yeah, no, no objection to this one.
Speaker 1 [15:55]: Councillor Graham DC no objection.
Speaker 1 [15:58]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [15:58]: Chair, any further comments?
Speaker 1 [16:01]: So we have a proposal and a second for no objection.
Speaker 1 [16:04]: All those in favour, thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [16:07]: That’s unanimous.
Speaker 1 [16:09]: Now planning application 88 Foxholes Hill proposed demolition of an existing side garage, construction of A2 Storey side extension, installation of first floor front balcony solar photovoltaic panels, and alterations to fenestrations and external materials.
Speaker 1 [16:34]: The National Grid has commented it has no assets in the area.
Speaker 1 [16:44]: OK.
Speaker 1 [16:44]: Southwest Water has also commented saying that this application requires a surface water drainage strategy demonstrating compliance with the runoff hierarchy, brackets with infiltration preferred close brackets, including justification for any alternative methods and coordination with relevant authorities.
Speaker 1 [17:06]: I’m just looking to see why.
Speaker 1 [17:11]: So they’re getting, I am confused by that comment.
Speaker 1 [17:14]: They’re getting rid of a of a side garage in that place on the same footprint.
Speaker 1 [17:19]: I think they’re building A2 Storey side extension and then doing some other things that are very much off the ground.
Speaker 1 [17:32]: There are I I will say this and I know there are so many more applications where this would be more relevant.
Speaker 1 [17:40]: I do not understand this and we see this quite a lot and it makes me wonder if they they pick at random some applications and comment on them.
Speaker 1 [17:51]: I have no words.
Speaker 1 [17:54]: So this is Exmouth neighbourhood plan EN 10.
Speaker 1 [17:58]: Thank you for redoing the stickers which is proposals for the development within.
Speaker 1 [18:03]: The development will only be permitted outside the built up area boundary where it would not harm distinctive landscape amenity and environmental qualities within which it is located, including landform and powers of settlement, important natural and man made features which contribute to the local landscape character etcetera and the adverse disruption of a public view which forms part of the distinctive character of the area.
Speaker 1 [18:28]: And it must also be EB2IN line with surrounding building styles.
Speaker 1 [18:36]: Councillor Graham DC Thank you Chair.
Speaker 1 [18:39]: Essentially no, no objection to this one.
Speaker 1 [18:42]: I think the proposals are very much in keeping with other developments that have gone on in the Foxholes area in recent times and I just think it is in keeping with that.
Speaker 1 [18:52]: So thank you, Councillor.
Speaker 1 [18:55]: I have a different view.
Speaker 1 [18:58]: Oh.
Speaker 1 [18:58]: Virtually every house in that road has got pitched roofs.
Speaker 1 [19:01]: This extension’s got a flat roof and it’s very conspicuous.
Speaker 1 [19:07]: I don’t think it fits in with with the get the streets in.
Speaker 1 [19:12]: So I would object.
Speaker 1 [19:13]: You would object?
Speaker 1 [19:15]: Yeah, definitely.
Speaker 1 [19:17]: OK does anybody else have any comments, perhaps put the other votions on?
Speaker 1 [19:22]: Yeah, I mean, I’ve which I did.
Speaker 1 [19:25]: David comment or Debbie?
Speaker 1 [19:38]: Yeah, please.
Speaker 1 [19:38]: David.
Speaker 1 [19:39]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [19:40]: When I looked at the elevation, I thought it just doesn’t look right.
Speaker 1 [19:43]: So I looked at the the the street, the the other houses.
Speaker 1 [19:46]: They’ve all got even the original garage has got a pitched roof and they could, you know, don’t object to the balcony.
Speaker 1 [19:55]: Lots of other houses up there, balconies.
Speaker 1 [19:57]: They can enjoy the view, but why not?
Speaker 1 [20:01]: Blend the house with this extension with all the with the street and put a pitch roof on.
Speaker 1 [20:06]: There doesn’t need to be a full pitch roof.
Speaker 1 [20:08]: It could be like the existing one.
Speaker 1 [20:10]: It would just it would fit in with with the existing house and with the street.
Speaker 1 [20:18]: Apart from that, let’s just say that.
Speaker 1 [20:21]: No problem really.
Speaker 1 [20:23]: OK.
Speaker 1 [20:23]: Just to say, Councillor Paul has commented and he has no objection.
Speaker 1 [20:34]: I’ll be brutally honest.
Speaker 1 [20:35]: I mean, I, I take your point, I personally think that it’s not a big enough planning consideration for East Haven to consider this if we object, you know, in terms of US in terms of that going to committee or anything.
Speaker 1 [21:00]: Could could we just have a quick look at straight G?
Speaker 1 [21:02]: Remind me is that, is that on the front or the back?
Speaker 1 [21:11]: I can’t remember that’s on the front.
Speaker 1 [21:52]: Applications somewhere I’m trying to find it along might be further along like look at this one for example.
Speaker 1 [21:58]: Yeah, I mean, I, I can go with the objection providing the roof is a bit roof if that is a bit easier.
Speaker 1 [22:07]: There were unfortunately that yeah, there were I’m sure there’s been some others along that road that have had some flat roofs.
Speaker 1 [22:15]: I’ve I’ve went along at the scene.
Speaker 1 [22:21]: I’ve never seen that before.
Speaker 1 [22:23]: Yeah, I think it’s possible to do that with you have to contact Google and you can get it blurred out.
Speaker 1 [22:29]: I’ve need to think this more and more.
Speaker 1 [22:31]: It would be a new thing that they’re they’ve started to be able to do.
Speaker 1 [22:35]: But I think you have to request.
Speaker 1 [22:37]: It’s a very localised storm.
Speaker 1 [22:41]: I am going to sorry Mike, I’m going to 2nd Councillor DCI think from the chair I take.
Speaker 1 [22:52]: I do take your point, but I do think you’re on a bit of a hiding to nothing with that.
Speaker 1 [23:03]: So we have A and we’ll let the room decide.
Speaker 1 [23:05]: We have a proposer and a seconder for no objection.
Speaker 1 [23:09]: All those in favour, all those against abstentions.
Speaker 1 [23:16]: Cool.
Speaker 1 [23:18]: Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [23:20]: So we now move on to 123456 789 hedgerow applications now for the benefit of the tape, is it that many something like that for the benefit of the tape, are we able to take them all in one go?
Speaker 1 [23:49]: But I for the benefit of the take, I will need to read out the numbers and and position right.
Speaker 1 [23:54]: So make yourself comfortable.
Speaker 1 [23:56]: OK.
Speaker 1 [23:56]: So we are now considering the planning applications for these are all for removal and reinstatement of hedgerow as far as I can see.
Speaker 1 [24:11]: And so I’m just going to bow into it.
Speaker 1 [24:14]: So these are planning applications.
Speaker 1 [24:16]: 260969 HRN.
Speaker 1 [24:20]: This is land adjacent Woodlands Farm Castle, and it is hedge number 19.
Speaker 1 [24:29]: 260970 HRN.
Speaker 1 [24:32]: Land northwest of crowned, the crowned and plantation off Mare Lane.
Speaker 1 [24:37]: And this is hedge #22.
Speaker 1 [24:41]: Planning application 260971 HRN land South of Crowdon plantation off Mare Lane.
Speaker 1 [24:48]: Hedge #23 Planning application 260972 HRN land South of Crowdon.
Speaker 1 [24:58]: Is it Crowdon or Croydon?
Speaker 1 [25:01]: Croydon plantation off Mare Lane.
Speaker 1 [25:04]: Should I start again?
Speaker 1 [25:05]: Hedge #24 260973 HRN Land southwest of Croydon slash Crowdon plantation off Mare Lane.
Speaker 1 [25:15]: Hedge #25.
Speaker 1 [25:17]: Planning application 260974 HRN Land South of Croydon plantation off Mare Lane.
Speaker 1 [25:24]: Hedge #26.
Speaker 1 [25:28]: Planning application 260975 HRN Land east of sewage treatment works off Mare Lane hedge #28.
Speaker 1 [25:40]: Planning application 260976 HRN Land southeast of sewage treatment works off Mare Lane hedge #29.
Speaker 1 [25:51]: Planning application 260977 HRN Land South of sewage treatment works off Mare Lane hedge #30.
Speaker 1 [26:00]: And that’s it.
Speaker 1 [26:02]: So thank you.
Speaker 1 [26:04]: So for each of those it seems to be standard that they wish to remove 10 metres of hedgerow to allow the rising main replacement and then to reinstate it once they have completed it.
Speaker 1 [26:17]: It’s important work for the town, we all know this, but we need to take this as it sits in front of us.
Speaker 1 [26:29]: So Councillor David Paul, we had no comments from consultees or representations other than David Paul who has said we already had no objection to the previous set of applications.
Speaker 1 [26:40]: And Southwest Water and Devon County Council seem to be aware of the issues and have a mitigation strategy in place, so he has no objection.
Speaker 1 [26:53]: We still didn’t let them on.
Speaker 1 [26:53]: We Councillor Mike Rosser.
Speaker 1 [26:57]: Yeah, I mean, clearly we would need this point being put in and it’s got to go through some hedges.
Speaker 1 [27:04]: There’s a 30, I think there’s a 33 page preliminary ecological assessment.
Speaker 1 [27:10]: I didn’t read all 33 pages, but it, it, I mean, clearly, obviously there’s going to be quite a significant loss of biodiversity.
Speaker 1 [27:20]: Cutting ancient hedges, removing ancient hedges and replacing the new ones.
Speaker 1 [27:26]: The, the, the, the assessment says that there’s, it’s exempt from the B what do you call it?
Speaker 1 [27:30]: Biodiversity, BDNGA biodiversity net game thing because it’s an existing development or a, a, a, a permitted development makes it exempt from that.
Speaker 1 [27:45]: So, well, if that’s the case, that’s the case.
Speaker 1 [27:48]: But I just think it’d be perhaps nice if Southwest thought to did some mitigation to to compensate, maybe dug a pond somewhere or, or, or, or.
Speaker 1 [27:58]: But anyway, I’ll stop waffling on no objection.
Speaker 1 [28:04]: You weren’t waffling.
Speaker 1 [28:04]: I think you make a fairpoint.
Speaker 1 [28:06]: I think you did make a fairpoint.
Speaker 1 [28:10]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [28:11]: I mean, they know that we need this and we know that we need this, but a little bit more thought about that might have been useful.
Speaker 1 [28:17]: But as you say, you have no objection.
Speaker 1 [28:19]: So.
Speaker 1 [28:20]: Councillor Graham DC yeah, it’s actually for the pipeline from Budley Salton, the new rising main from Budley Salton.
Speaker 1 [28:27]: But the need is just as much there as it is here.
Speaker 1 [28:30]: It is obviously the proposals are are just very like the scheme we already approved, the one coming out from Mayor Rd where they yes, take out sections of hedgerow and they replant with native species.
Speaker 1 [28:43]: But I, I, I take Councillor Ross’s point of view.
Speaker 1 [28:46]: Let’s, let’s put in a little request that not only they replace with native hedging as as is if you like, but if there’s any opportunity to increase the bionic net diversity with Southwest Water, please consider it and, and yeah, make an effort, shall we say.
Speaker 1 [29:05]: So yeah, I’ll support the proposal.
Speaker 1 [29:08]: We could certainly add that to the notes, can’t we?
Speaker 1 [29:11]: That would be good.
Speaker 1 [29:13]: And maybe you stab and we’ll pass that on.
Speaker 1 [29:15]: Do you have any further comments?
Speaker 1 [29:16]: Yeah, Councillor Dumper, just just a couple of questions.
Speaker 1 [29:20]: Actually 1 is, are these within the national landscape?
Speaker 1 [29:25]: Are these within the national landscape?
Speaker 1 [29:31]: Yeah, right.
Speaker 1 [29:32]: And the second question then Councillor also mentions permitted development.
Speaker 1 [29:39]: If they are permitted development, why?
Speaker 1 [29:41]: Why are they in front of us now?
Speaker 1 [29:43]: Good question.
Speaker 1 [29:47]: I suspect the sewage treatment works is probably within permitted development, but maybe the all the actual pipe stuff is the pipe extension work is is probably class of permitted development, but the facilitative way it work to install it perhaps isn’t.
Speaker 1 [30:06]: That would be my interpretation, but we I mean we could check Mike.
Speaker 1 [30:11]: Yeah, I mean that comment was in the Ecology report commissioned by the applicant.
Speaker 1 [30:17]: So I think it’s worth asking that question.
Speaker 1 [30:20]: Yeah, we can add that as well.
Speaker 1 [30:22]: Subject to those things, though.
Speaker 1 [30:25]: Sorry, Tim, you’ve finished.
Speaker 1 [30:26]: Did you?
Speaker 1 [30:27]: Yeah, subject to those things.
Speaker 1 [30:29]: We do have a proposal and a seconder for no objection.
Speaker 1 [30:31]: All those in favour, all those against and abstentions.
Speaker 1 [30:38]: Cool.
Speaker 1 [30:39]: Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [30:40]: So much to the agenda, we now move to planning application 252652303 M at Major Fold site of the former oil and petroleum gas refinery on Albion Hill.
Speaker 1 [31:05]: The erection of two apartment blocks comprising 22 apartments, Class C3 with associated access, car parking, landscaping, open space and associate associated works at the form of gas works on Albion Hill.
Speaker 1 [31:19]: These are amended plans, amended and additional plans for information.
Speaker 1 [31:25]: So in February we said about the original plans.
Speaker 1 [31:30]: We have an objection saying that the scale and design of the proposal is out of keeping with its setting.
Speaker 1 [31:36]: While members have no objection in principle to the redevelopment of the brownfield site is considered that the modern box like appearance lacks character and fails to integrate with the existing streetscape or of the nearby conservation area.
Speaker 1 [31:50]: The development was regarded as visually intrusive and not complementary to its surroundings and it was therefore considered to be contrary to ENP plan policy EB2, which requires new development to respect surrounding building styles and demonstrate a high standard of design.
Speaker 1 [32:10]: So we are now talking about the amended plans.
Speaker 1 [32:12]: The Police Architectural Liaison Officer does not wish to comment further.
Speaker 1 [32:19]: The NHS requests 51,000 lbs S one O 6 contribution to mitigate the added pressure on already full healthcare services and ensure sustainable, timely care for the growing population.
Speaker 1 [32:31]: Which is very interesting when we look at the amount and their attitude when we were talking about the juice and development when it was not quite as worded in that way.
Speaker 1 [32:44]: That’s an interesting point which I will take away with me.
Speaker 1 [32:47]: The Environment Agency do not wish to come in further so comments since the last consultation.
Speaker 1 [32:53]: So that’s to the amended plans, I assume the first.
Speaker 1 [32:59]: No, it’s not actually, is it?
Speaker 1 [33:02]: This is again to the original plans looking at the dates or is it, I don’t know, holding object.
Speaker 1 [33:08]: So the landscape architect holds their objection, saying the scheme appears over developed and requires significant design improvements, clearer details and better landscaping to meet policy standards and ensure quality amenity.
Speaker 1 [33:25]: This I think is to the previous, the first application but came in after we spoke about it.
Speaker 1 [33:31]: The Flood Risk team objects to the application due to insufficient surface water drainage details and requires further information.
Speaker 1 [33:39]: There’s been no updated comment regarding the amended plans.
Speaker 1 [33:44]: Southwest Water raises no objection confirming service capacity is available, but requires the scheme to follow the drainage hierarchy, obtain approval for sewer connections, and incorporate water efficiency measures.
Speaker 1 [34:02]: E Evans, Tree Officer objects due to the continued loss and impact on important boundary woodland, warning that revised scheme must fully retain it or face likely refusal with the tree protection.
Speaker 1 [34:14]: The TPO to be imposed for protection.
Speaker 1 [34:18]: No updated comment received regarding the amended plans.
Speaker 1 [34:21]: The District Ecologist said after we discussed the previous one, they have no fundamental objection but required further information and mitigation to address impacts on protected species etcetera.
Speaker 1 [34:32]: The Conservation Officer objects on scale massing design and says that materials would harm the setting and character of the nearby conservation area.
Speaker 1 [34:41]: The Housing Officer supports a flexible approach to affordable housing, agreeing that a cascade from on site provision to a commuted sum is reasonable given current market constraints, subject to appropriate conditions.
Speaker 1 [34:56]: County highways have commented about two months after we heard this and long after the closing date.
Speaker 1 [35:06]: They have no objection.
Speaker 1 [35:07]: The scheme provides adequate access, parking and sustainable travel options.
Speaker 1 [35:14]: Excuse me a moment.
Speaker 1 [35:19]: So we have 7 representations to the new to the amended plans.
Speaker 1 [35:26]: Saying that the proposal remains overly dense, too tall and poorly designed in the area would worsen traffic, parking and safety issues, would harm wildlife and local character, and raised concerns about contamination and the need for flats over houses.
Speaker 1 [35:42]: 59 representations in respect to the original application.
Speaker 1 [35:46]: Councillor David Poor maintains his objection, saying nothing much has changed and the height of the block seemed to be the same.
Speaker 1 [35:54]: He still has major concerns with access to the site to and from Albion Hill as it’s obscured partially for pedestrians like himself.
Speaker 1 [36:04]: This is Exmouth Neighbourhood Plan policy EB2 there must be around aware of surrounding building styles and H2 which is to meet the identified housing needle housing development within the built up area boundary on sites that more than 10 properties should seek to deliver 25% affordable units.
Speaker 1 [36:28]: So the amended these two amended plans do reduce the height and number of proposed apartments from 26 to 22.
Speaker 1 [36:34]: Enhanced tree and hedgerow planting.
Speaker 1 [36:37]: Good Lord.
Speaker 1 [36:38]: Right.
Speaker 1 [36:39]: OK, so counts.
Speaker 1 [36:41]: I can’t remember where we got to.
Speaker 1 [36:42]: Councillor Graham DC Thank you chair.
Speaker 1 [36:48]: So I just mentioned in your your last sentence there that it didn’t affect the height.
Speaker 1 [36:53]: I thought it the height was the same despite the reduction in the number of flats.
Speaker 1 [37:00]: If it that is the case in terms of mass and and overbearing this sorry.
Speaker 1 [37:07]: Yeah, Lisa, Lisa and I examined the application.
Speaker 1 [37:13]: The supporting letter said it was reducing the height.
Speaker 1 [37:18]: We can check that again though.
Speaker 1 [37:20]: Are you able to?
Speaker 1 [37:29]: Not a problem at all.
Speaker 1 [37:30]: Not a problem at all.
Speaker 1 [37:38]: It’s in the resubmission cover letter.
Speaker 1 [37:43]: No, what it says is it says that prior to submitting the application the applicant had submitted a pre application inquiry to East Devon District Council and the scheme presented at pre application stage was considerably larger than that being proposed in the application proposing 36 flats set across two blocks of three and four storeys.
Speaker 1 [38:10]: And then it says during the pre application stage, it says that the applicant made significant efforts take on board the advice by modifying the design and the quantum of proposed apartments was reduced significantly to 26 apartments and the scale of the proposed blocks was reduced.
Speaker 1 [38:30]: Block 1 was reduced to 2 1/2 stories to place it in keeping with the surrounding development and the distinctive terraces within the conservation area on nearby Albion Street.
Speaker 1 [38:42]: And then it says a number of revisions to the design of the proposal have been made, taking into account comments received from the officers and the consultees.
Speaker 1 [38:53]: It says the number of flats proposed has been reduced from 26 to 22.
Speaker 1 [39:02]: This is this has been made directly to address the urban design officers comments and then tree planting and hedgerows.
Speaker 1 [39:16]: I thought we’d picked up that they’d reduced the height, but maybe they hadn’t.
Speaker 1 [39:22]: Maybe the comment we saw was in respect of the I think they reduced the height from the pre.
Speaker 1 [39:28]: Yeah, yeah, you might be right then, Graham.
Speaker 1 [39:31]: Yeah, basically I did read that document, but I have to confess scan read it as opposed to went through every I and every T and I was a bit concerned.
Speaker 1 [39:44]: But even even with when you look at some of the drawings of the CAD, CAD drawings and so on, the impact of the blocks on on the locality is still significant in my view.
Speaker 1 [39:56]: So I think that that’s that is a concern to me about the height and well actually the total sort of volume if you like of of the building block 1, I think it is, is virtually adjacent to the pavement.
Speaker 1 [40:12]: And very, very close to the roadway.
Speaker 1 [40:14]: Therefore, I find that, you know, quite intrusive when you’re looking at if you like the sight lines and that, sorry, I’ve got an 84 sheet chairman.
Speaker 1 [40:26]: But I, I think there are also issues regarding sort of loss of daylight and, and, and, and privacy.
Speaker 1 [40:32]: And certainly with balconies, the heights this the proposed development is I think that it is totally out of keeping and totally out of character with the with the adjacent properties and with the street scene.
Speaker 1 [40:45]: I I have to confess and sorry, yeah, I I do have concerns about the parking access.
Speaker 1 [40:56]: I know highways have commented but I’m sorry, can I beg to differ with highways view that we know Albion Hills are very restricted Hwy with parking.
Speaker 1 [41:07]: There was quite a lot of pedestrian traffic and so on.
Speaker 1 [41:09]: That does concern me.
Speaker 1 [41:11]: Even if the display lines are there, the amount of traffic, I don’t think there’s sufficient parking spaces within.
Speaker 1 [41:18]: Well there may be for one car per flat, but again, I’m not sure that’s sufficient nowadays.
Speaker 1 [41:25]: And therefore what’s there going to be an impact on street parking in the whole of that area?
Speaker 1 [41:30]: We know even in adjacent Windsor Square there are there are some issues there.
Speaker 1 [41:39]: Sorry, one of the objectors raised the point about the wildlife and, and although the actual developer may be trying to mitigate the, the impact on, on wildlife, they do raise a point and it’s something I don’t know, but I would like it possibly clarified as you can step in the level if you like, about the fact that it is a sort of quite a wild area.
Speaker 1 [42:03]: It’s been, it’s been redundant for a long time now.
Speaker 1 [42:06]: And therefore you are getting wildlife in that area for feeding purposes or for nesting purposes or whatever, which I think is potentially has to be lost.
Speaker 1 [42:17]: Now we all I think accept it as a bit of an ice or area.
Speaker 1 [42:22]: But I do think that the proposal that’s come before us is, is just too much for that area and I just object to it.
Speaker 1 [42:32]: Absolutely fine.
Speaker 1 [42:33]: Quick question.
Speaker 1 [42:35]: I may have completely imagined this, but the tree officer talked during the first application about getting a TPO for the trees on that.
Speaker 1 [42:44]: I have vague recollections of us talking about that.
Speaker 1 [42:48]: I have a collection that they did OK.
Speaker 1 [42:51]: So I think if you know, I mean 2nd.
Speaker 1 [43:00]: Oh, please.
Speaker 1 [43:01]: Anyway, Mike, here you go for it.
Speaker 1 [43:02]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [43:03]: Because following the last application of contact trees and asked them to assess for TPOS on some of the trees there.
Speaker 1 [43:10]: And they, they, in my view, they provided an excellent assessment.
Speaker 1 [43:14]: And a lot of the area that they’re going to that the applicants want to build on is actually protected by TPOS.
Speaker 1 [43:24]: So the developer in answer to that is trying to say, well, the TPOS are, you know, the trees shouldn’t be protected because they’re not high quality.
Speaker 1 [43:35]: But what, what I find surprising is the ecologist and the tree officer don’t seem to be singing the same tune.
Speaker 1 [43:43]: The tree officer is saying it’s a valuable area for wildlife, for for biodiversity, but that doesn’t seem to be mirrored by the ecologist, which I find disappointing.
Speaker 1 [43:55]: I think the other, the other person who raised concerns was the urban.
Speaker 1 [44:00]: Urban, what they call urban design plan.
Speaker 1 [44:02]: Urban, the landscape.
Speaker 1 [44:05]: No, the no, not the, not the landscape, the urban.
Speaker 1 [44:09]: I can’t think the right title.
Speaker 1 [44:12]: Urban planner or urban designer.
Speaker 1 [44:15]: That’s it.
Speaker 1 [44:15]: Urban designer.
Speaker 1 [44:16]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [44:19]: So, yeah, no, I would second the objection for, you know, the grounds that have already been stated, but also for the fact that they want to build on an area that is protected by TPOS, which we can definitely write down.
Speaker 1 [44:34]: Lisa has just confirmed on the screen that there are TPOS in place for the for the trees there.
Speaker 1 [44:38]: So yeah, thank you.
Speaker 1 [44:41]: To be fair, I think the ecologist has made a similar point.
Speaker 1 [44:47]: Yeah, so, well, this was to the first, the first application.
Speaker 1 [44:50]: They have no fundamental objection, but they need information and mitigation to address the impacts of the protected species, ensure compliance with biodiversity net gain requirements, preferably on site, secure habit habitat mitigation payments and a data and get a detailed ecological management and enhancement measure.
Speaker 1 [45:09]: So I think you know, yeah, no, no, that’s fine, that’s fine.
Speaker 1 [45:15]: But I just meant to say that the only way that you can mitigate is to reduce the the area that they’re going to build on.
Speaker 1 [45:21]: Not two blocks, one block in my queue.
Speaker 1 [45:26]: That’s that’s fine.
Speaker 1 [45:27]: So we have a does anybody have some any comments?
Speaker 1 [45:32]: Councillor Colbert Yeah, just two.
Speaker 1 [45:35]: I actually would support appropriate development on this brownfield site will be will be issues with wildlife and everything there.
Speaker 1 [45:45]: But I think brownfield sites should be seriously considered in terms of highways.
Speaker 1 [45:54]: There are huge numbers of young people and children that go up and down there because you’ve got Saint Joseph’s at the top, you’ve got the Beacon at the bottom and you’ve got extra roads.
Speaker 1 [46:03]: So there’s quite a flow from sort of the Fear Ave side and, and up and down that hill.
Speaker 1 [46:11]: So I, I would think it wasn’t terribly safe highways wise.
Speaker 1 [46:17]: I think it’s fair to say that quite a lot of people have said they don’t object to the idea of development on the site because it is entirely appropriate with all of the policies in terms of being a brownfield site.
Speaker 1 [46:26]: But Councillor Dunper couple of points.
Speaker 1 [46:30]: And I mean, I, I still think it, it is over development and overmassing what it is.
Speaker 1 [46:39]: I would agree with Councillor Diane Conduit that that we do need to develop brownfield sites.
Speaker 1 [46:46]: But I would also comment and follow up on on the point that was made by Councillor Graham Deasy, which is that although it’s a brownfield site, it has been left vacant for many years.
Speaker 1 [47:02]: And it to me it’s rather reminiscent of the boxing club site, which in the end was agreed by East Devon District Council, but that had an ecology of its own, if you like, that had developed over the years since it was a quarry and a brickworks.
Speaker 1 [47:25]: And, and I, I think ecologists should look more carefully.
Speaker 1 [47:30]: I think the comment that Councillor Mike Russell makes is also relevant.
Speaker 1 [47:36]: And you know, when you read out what had been said, it was commented in particular on protected species.
Speaker 1 [47:45]: And I think that what the district ecologists tend to do is look at specifically a protected species.
Speaker 1 [47:54]: I’m not an expert on biodiversity net gain and I make that that point, but I do feel that that there needs to be a wider consideration of ecosystems and how they work and the protection of those ecosystems as well as just protected species.
Speaker 1 [48:15]: Anyway, that’s all I’d like to say.
Speaker 1 [48:18]: No, thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [48:22]: So do you have enough things to write on a OK, assuming this is going to go, as I suspect it might, reading the room.
Speaker 1 [48:35]: So we have a proposal and a second in favour of objection.
Speaker 1 [48:39]: All those in favour.
Speaker 1 [48:42]: That’s unanimous.
Speaker 1 [48:44]: Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [48:44]: Right, so we’re now going to move to town.
Speaker 1 [48:46]: I must at this point the recording will not pause, but I do need to go and get some water.
Speaker 1 [48:51]: So for the benefit of the tape, the chair will leave the room, fill up a cup.
Speaker 1 [48:54]: OK Thank you very much, Lisa.
Speaker 1 [48:56]: We’re going to struggle otherwise.
Speaker 1 [49:00]: The town clerk has instead left the room, so we moved to the town ward.
Speaker 1 [49:05]: Planning application 260616 full.
Speaker 1 [49:10]: This is for the Grove Public House on the Esplanade for the proposal.
Speaker 1 [49:17]: The proposal is for the erection of a new metal frame, retractable roof pergola to replace existing stretch tent, a new aluminium roof link between the new pergola and the existing building, new paved floor finish to the new covered area.
Speaker 1 [49:36]: We have no comments from consultees or that is in a conservation area.
Speaker 1 [49:40]: Isn’t it Ron’s because we’ve we’ve asked for the conservation officer.
Speaker 1 [49:45]: Yeah, they have been consulted, but they haven’t responded as of yet.
Speaker 1 [49:48]: But yeah, they haven’t responded as yet.
Speaker 1 [49:51]: So should respond eventually, but obviously they struggle with capacity to meet the deadline.
Speaker 1 [49:59]: Yeah, and highways have not been consulted.
Speaker 1 [50:01]: We have one comment which asks for clarification on the proposed structure’s height and whether it will be taller than the existing canopy.
Speaker 1 [50:09]: Because if you look on the plans, it doesn’t seem to say so.
Speaker 1 [50:13]: This is excellent.
Speaker 1 [50:14]: I managed to get one to the tool.
Speaker 1 [50:18]: There is a tool function.
Speaker 1 [50:20]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [50:22]: And if I’ve used it correctly, I think it might be 3.6 metres high.
Speaker 1 [50:29]: OK, thank you for that and good use of technology.
Speaker 1 [50:37]: So this is EB2 where it must be mindful of surrounding building styles, and also EB1 where the development proposal should seek to conserve heritage assets, including traditional shop frontages and historic St furniture.
Speaker 1 [50:53]: And the bit that’s relevant would be the, well, it’s not established, but the Exmouth Register of Historical and Architectural Features.
Speaker 1 [51:04]: So.
Speaker 1 [51:05]: Oh, we’ll go to Diane first.
Speaker 1 [51:06]: Sorry.
Speaker 1 [51:07]: Yeah, Diane can’t still come to it.
Speaker 1 [51:10]: I spoke in principle.
Speaker 1 [51:12]: I don’t think I would object to this.
Speaker 1 [51:14]: I suppose it is about the conservation and any comments that come forward from the conservation officer.
Speaker 1 [51:21]: I mean they have got the tented area there now which goes above the wall and it’s got, it’s quite visible.
Speaker 1 [51:26]: So this might be actually less visible.
Speaker 1 [51:33]: So in principle I would have, I have no objections other than awaiting the conservation officers comments.
Speaker 1 [51:42]: I think that’s the key for me as well.
Speaker 1 [51:44]: I know that in the past with the stretched tent they’ve had safety issues, but it does look to me to be more of a it just looks slightly more organic than this than this construction proposal proposes.
Speaker 1 [52:04]: I purse.
Speaker 1 [52:04]: I, I probably would object to it because if you look at, although it’s tucked away from sort of the view on the sea front, from what from further away, if, if you look at the beautiful old building, that’s the pub and then you put this next to it, they’re entirely incongruous.
Speaker 1 [52:26]: And I, I, I’m not sure it’s the best way of, of doing this.
Speaker 1 [52:35]: It’s a very well, it’s kind of a modern, I mean, although it’s permanent, it looks like a temporary structure.
Speaker 1 [52:42]: I don’t think it fits with the surrounding area and I don’t think it fits with the building it’s next to.
Speaker 1 [52:49]: And I think the, you know, the sort of the brushed aluminium and yeah, I don’t know, it just, it doesn’t, it doesn’t feel right.
Speaker 1 [52:58]: I’d be happy with it if the conservation officer had come back and said he was OK with it.
Speaker 1 [53:02]: They were OK with it.
Speaker 1 [53:06]: So what do we do here?
Speaker 1 [53:06]: Can we put the elevations up on the screen, please?
Speaker 1 [53:12]: Yeah, I suppose I’m just looking at the aluminium and thinking, well, you’ve got this sort of grey stone and all of that around there.
Speaker 1 [53:19]: So whether that would would be, whether it would be that obvious.
Speaker 1 [53:24]: Obviously if you’re in the garden up against the building it would be but fruitous.
Speaker 1 [53:30]: I’ll just put on the screen here what the existing arrangement is.
Speaker 1 [53:35]: See that to me looks fairly organic.
Speaker 1 [53:36]: It is, you know, it’s not a permanent structure.
Speaker 1 [53:40]: I mean, it’s potentially unsafe, but and that’s why they want to get rid of it.
Speaker 1 [53:44]: But that’s a retractable roof part.
Speaker 1 [53:55]: I think if you scroll up to the top of the page, it’s there.
Speaker 1 [53:57]: Oh, no, there we go.
Speaker 1 [53:58]: There we are.
Speaker 1 [54:00]: See.
Speaker 1 [54:02]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [54:05]: Don’t know if there’s a better plan on there.
Speaker 1 [54:07]: There is floor plan.
Speaker 1 [54:14]: I I think what we had there was probably the best, the best view of it.
Speaker 1 [54:17]: Yeah.
Speaker 1 [54:19]: So I’m kind of for me because I couldn’t make a comparison and I was thinking this would be flat.
Speaker 1 [54:26]: So it might be a lot less visible.
Speaker 1 [54:30]: I found it really difficult.
Speaker 1 [54:31]: So say in principle, I think it’s really difficult to judge for the information that we’ve been provided.
Speaker 1 [54:40]: Does anybody else have any, any comments to help us get us out of this, this kind of impasse that we’re in?
Speaker 1 [54:47]: Sorry, you said you’d second it.
Speaker 1 [54:49]: If no, I, I probably not actually, I I would feel more comfortable with with the idea of it.
Speaker 1 [55:01]: If they, I, I personally, I don’t think I could because I think it looks wrong, especially if it comes up over the over the wall.
Speaker 1 [55:12]: OK.
Speaker 1 [55:15]: OK.
Speaker 1 [55:16]: Councillor Mike Rosser.
Speaker 1 [55:21]: So that’s the retractable roof.
Speaker 1 [55:23]: That’s like a top view of it and that’s showing that those bits retract back somehow and roll up or something.
Speaker 1 [55:28]: I don’t know.
Speaker 1 [55:30]: Is is that elevation or plan?
Speaker 1 [55:33]: Is it looking down?
Speaker 1 [55:34]: That’s looking down, that’s looking down.
Speaker 1 [55:36]: So the elevation from the front is the one on the top right.
Speaker 1 [55:39]: So if you’re at the front of the pub, you’ve got the pub and then to the right of that you’ll have that view where the cursor is now doesn’t look good.
Speaker 1 [55:46]: Not especially where is it the Grove?
Speaker 1 [55:55]: Wait, wait till you vote more.
Speaker 1 [55:58]: So what we said, Diane, are you because are you, are you happy to object?
Speaker 1 [56:04]: I don’t want to feel like I’ve yes, OK, because I think that’s going to come up over the wall, isn’t it significantly so.
Speaker 1 [56:13]: OK.
Speaker 1 [56:14]: So we do have a proposer and a seconder for objection on the grounds of it being incongruous for the building styles being too tall and what else you’ve just said all those in favour of objection.
Speaker 1 [56:32]: OK, that’s unanimous.
Speaker 1 [56:33]: Thank you.
Speaker 1 [56:40]: So we now move to planning application OK Planning application 260928 Full 31 New North Road The installation of a commercial kitchen extraction flu.
Speaker 1 [56:56]: This we have no comments from.
Speaker 1 [56:59]: We do have comments from statutory consultees.
Speaker 1 [57:03]: The contaminated Land Officer has no concerns and Environmental Health has concerned about a potential noise and odour impacts from the proposed kitchen extraction system and request detailed assessments and mitigation plans before making a recommendation.
Speaker 1 [57:18]: I’m a bit confused by this one.
Speaker 1 [57:20]: It’s because I immediately assumed it was for the proposed snooker club but it’s not.
Speaker 1 [57:24]: I don’t think it’s for.
Speaker 1 [57:26]: Is it a builder?
Speaker 1 [57:27]: A plumbers, a plumbing supply.
Speaker 1 [57:31]: Yeah, well, it looks to me as though it’s a change of use from the plumbing supply thing to making meals for some children’s homes that are coming into town.
Speaker 1 [57:42]: Right.
Speaker 1 [57:43]: So that was the bit I couldn’t say.
Speaker 1 [57:45]: So I think first of all, much as that sounds like a worthy, A worthy enterprise, a really worthy enterprise.
Speaker 1 [57:52]: I don’t know if putting a commercial kitchen in the middle of a residential St without seeking a change of use.
Speaker 1 [58:00]: Because I think if you they are different use classes and I think you do need if if it’s at volume and that’s its sole purpose as a building, they would need to apply for a change of use.
Speaker 1 [58:13]: And I have real reservations as to whether or not in the middle of a residential street is, is, is a good place to do that.
Speaker 1 [58:21]: However, the environmental health officer, of course, read this has concern about potential noise and odour impacts.
Speaker 1 [58:28]: No, I didn’t.
Speaker 1 [58:29]: I did say this from the proposed kitchen extraction system and wants detailed assessments and mitigation plans before making a recommendation on the basis of that.
Speaker 1 [58:38]: That goes against what I read this morning entirely.
Speaker 1 [58:48]: Yeah, it’s interesting.
Speaker 1 [58:48]: So in their in their statement of support, planning statement of support, they say that the use remains within Class E and therefore does not constitute A meritorial change of use.
Speaker 1 [59:07]: Notwithstanding that the system will serve a commercial kitchen used for preparation of hot and cold food for off site consumption within childcare settings settings.
Speaker 1 [59:17]: No food will be sold directly to the public from the premises.
Speaker 1 [59:22]: So small scale ancillary fruit food prep inside an existing Class E premises, that’s fine.
Speaker 1 [59:29]: But is it if it’s a proper commercial kitchen operation serving the public does I guess maybe that’s public being public facing, I don’t know.
Speaker 1 [59:45]: Yeah, I don’t know.
Speaker 1 [59:47]: OK, well, we’ll, we’ll worry about the application itself.
Speaker 1 [59:50]: I would object on the grounds that the environmental health officer themselves are saying they don’t know, they don’t know enough to be able to say if this is going to be dangerous or not for them.
Speaker 1 [01:00:01]: So or, you know, interrupting or disturbing local people.
Speaker 1 [01:00:08]: I I would like it written that a commercial kitchen in the middle of a residential St doesn’t seem right.
Speaker 1 [01:00:14]: So, yeah.
Speaker 1 [01:00:15]: Councillor Diane Condrett.
Speaker 1 [01:00:18]: OK.
Speaker 1 [01:00:18]: Any other comments at all?
Speaker 1 [01:00:21]: So a proposer and a seconder for objection.
Speaker 1 [01:00:24]: All those in favour.
Speaker 1 [01:00:26]: Thank you very much.
Speaker 1 [01:00:28]: Thanks for coming, Andrew, but we have nothing in with you.
Speaker 1 [01:00:33]: Yeah, so agenda item, seven other items.
Speaker 1 [01:00:38]: I guess me and Councillor Dunbush should declare that we’re members of the licencing committee because this is a pavement licence.
Speaker 1 [01:00:45]: That’s you know, but just for completeness, this is a we don’t need to comment if we don’t want to, but this is for a pavement licence for the Strand on the 20th of June for Armed Forces Day 10 traders for the Armed Forces event.
Speaker 1 [01:01:04]: Does anybody have any comments at all?
Speaker 1 [01:01:07]: No, so we don’t need to comment on that.
Speaker 1 [01:01:09]: That’s fine.
Speaker 1 [01:01:11]: There’s no further items or information.
Speaker 1 [01:01:14]: We have three planning decisions, Lipscomb Ave, the Strand and 12 Green Hill Ave.
Speaker 1 [01:01:20]: We had no objection and E haven’t approved.
Speaker 1 [01:01:24]: So thank you very much everyone.
Speaker 1 [01:01:25]: I’m gonna remind you that the recording, we’ll carry on for a couple of seconds after I’ve banged the hammer.
Speaker 1 [01:01:29]: So thank you very much and thank you for coming.
Speaker 1 [01:01:32]: Goodbye.
